iGeo 2006, Теренна работа — Задача 5. Question 5
6th International Geography Olympiad, Brisbane, Australia. Fieldwork Test · 30 юни 2006 г. · 5 т.
Fieldwork Test. Part A — Question Booklet
Friday 30 June 2.00 - 3.15pm
You may have with you stationery items, a calculator, a language dictionary, and your annotated map and notes from this morning’s fieldwork.
Answer the questions in the answer booklet provided
Fieldwork Test. Part B — Question Booklet
Saturday 1 July 9.00 - 10.30am
You may have with you stationery items, a calculator, a language dictionary, your Answer Booklet from Part A, the aerial photo distributed during the fieldwork, your annotated map and notes from this morning’s fieldwork.
Answer the questions in the answer booklet provided
(Question 1 and 2 were in Part A)
Условие
Decision-making task
Figure 2 and the text below relate to Questions 5 and 6 at the bottom of the page.
The block highlighted in Figure 2 is approximately 950 sq metres, and has not yet been developed. There are three proposals being considered for this block:
- a three story building – the ground floor would be retail (for example, coffee shop, Oxfam shop, budget clothing shop); the two floors above would be single bedroom units aimed at the student market
- a three story building – the ground floor would be a gymnasium and associated health services (for example, doctors’ surgery, health food shop); the two floors above would provide space for offices for companies such as small publishing companies, technology support companies, advertising companies and the like
- a three story building, comprising one and two bedroom units aimed at the over 55 years old market
You are required to make a decision as to the most appropriate of the three proposals.
In reaching your decision you should consider the information presented and gathered during yesterday’s fieldwork, and the data in your completed land use map (from Question 1) and your age-sex pyramid (from Question 2).
Question 5 (5 marks - in point form)
Evaluate the three proposals using the criteria listed below. Present your answer by completing the matrix in the answer booklet.
- the building should complement developments already completed or planned for the village
- the building should be in keeping with the idea of a sustainable urban community
- the building should not detract from the natural and social environmental qualities of the overall village community
Question 5. Evaluation matrix
| Criteria / Proposals | the building should complement developments already completed or planned for the village | the building should be in keeping with the idea of a sustainable urban community | the building should not detract from the natural and social environmental qualities of the overall village community |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. a three story building – the ground floor would be retail (for example, coffee shop, Oxfam shop, budget clothing shop); the two floors above would be single bedroom units aimed at the student market | |||
| 2. a three story building – the ground floor would be a gymnasium and associated health services (for example, doctors’ surgery, health food shop); the two floors above would provide space for offices for companies such as small publishing companies, technology support companies, advertising companies and the like | |||
| 3. a three story building, comprising one and two bedroom units aimed at the over 55 years old market |
Решение
Question 5 - Evaluation Matrix - 5 Marks
| All squares complete with at least 1 valid attribute listed [positive or negative] | 5 marks |
| All squares, with the exception of 1 or 2, complete with at least 1 valid attribute listed [positive or negative] | 4 |
| All squares, with the exception of 3 or 4, complete with at least 1 valid attribute listed [positive or negative] | 3 |
| All squares, with the exception of 5 or 6, complete with at least 1 valid attribute listed [positive or negative] | 2 |
| All squares, with the exception of 7 or 8, complete with at least 1 valid attribute listed [positive or negative] | 1 |
Examples of valid attributes
| Proposalscriteria | the development needs to complement developments already completed or planned | the development should be in keeping with the idea of a sustainable urban development | the development should not detract from the natural and social environmental qualities of the overall village |
|---|---|---|---|
| A 3-storey development, the ground floor of which will be retail [eg, coffee shop, Oxfam shop, budget clothing shop] and the two floors above being single bedroom units aimed at the student market. | - mixed use [+] - already student accommodation [-] - sufficient retail already? | - mixed use [+] | - contributes to sense of neighbourhood [+] |
| A 3-storey development, the ground floor of which is a gymnasium and associated health services ,the two floors remaining providing space for offices for companies such as small publishing companies, technology support companies, and the like. | - utilized by all age groups [+] - already a gym [-] - these companies could interface well with those already in village [+] | - mixed use [+] - uses space effectively [+] | - use by existing and new community [+] - add to ‘sense of community’.[+] - not necessarily a positive for sense of neighbourhood. [-] |
| A 3-storey development, comprising one and two bedroom units aimed at the over 55 market. | - already seniors accommodation [-] - a distance from other services for the elderly [-] - more suitable location for older groups than some already existing housing [+] | - one use building [-] - unsustainable [-] - caters for one age group only [-] | - seniors may feel isolated [-] - may assist to create sense of neighbourhood [+] |
Оригинал в Архива: 2006FWtest.pdf · официални решения: 2006FWmarkingscheme.pdf